Monday, August 9, 2010

Single Diesel or Twin Outboard

Single Diesel
Pros
  • Increased Cockpit Fish-ability
  • COG shift forward slightly, better for running in rough seas
  • Engine bulkhead already in place
  • Tuna Door can be put on transom
  • Emergency kicker needed (E-Tec Diesel Outboard)
Cons
  • Longer Build time
  • excessive amount of time calculating prop, shaft, and rudder locations and aligmnet
  • keel and frames must be cut back to allow for shaft
  • shaft would run through bottom connection point (potential weak point / leakage occuring)
  • Helm must be designed for Engine Room Access
  • Vessel will not be able to be in shallow water or run aground
  • Gas Honda Generator will not run on Diesel for over night canyon trips
Twin Outboard
Pros
  • Increased Safety and reliability, 2 Motors
  • Better performance, adjustable propulsion line
  • Quick installation  no excess build time
  • Ease of engine maintenance
  • Helm area arrangement not affected by engines
  • Hull structure would remain unchanged 
  • Gas generator able to tie into fuel supply
Cons
  • Fish-ability limited at transom
  • Tuna door has to be small or on side of hull
  • Transom access form dock makes it hard to board vessel at some locations
  • Double maintenance costs
While engine selection can still be either or,  both options have excellent reasons for using them. as for the inboard, shaft, prop and the transmission would pose a long shop time to calculate and build a surface which would be able to support the engine. At this point i am still planing on going with twin outboards. This can change in the future, but a definite decision is not required until the bottom shell plating is done.

No comments:

Post a Comment